[For a moment, Fenimore lets Buffy's hand rest on her shoulder, even if she is tense both by touch and by sight. But then she tries to push Buffy's arm away with her own, a clear message of "don't touch me."]

What do you know?! You have no idea! The things that happen out here are a joke! But when they kidnap people, it's just like.... [She stands, suddenly, but doesn't turn to face Buffy again.] She should never have had to go through that! Even when-- And now she has to deal with it! It's not fair!

[Her low sleep state and high stress from Shirley's disappearance makes her even more selfish than usual and causes her to entirely forget the possibility that Buffy could have easily been mallynapped in her time here.]